Telehealth reimbursement parity spurs insurer concerns of overutilization

(Image: Geber86/Getty Illustrations or photos) Telehealth has undergone a radical transformation in the course of

(Image: Geber86/Getty Illustrations or photos)

Telehealth has undergone a radical transformation in the course of the training course of the COVID-19 pandemic. In a minimal far more than 14 months, it has evolved from a area of interest supplying that allowed people to see clinicians while keeping socially distant to starting to be a large part of the potential of healthcare. 

Telehealth was a practical services in advance of the pandemic, but it was reimbursed at lessen premiums than in-place of work visits. There have been geographical limits that put strict parameters on where a affected person could accessibility digital healthcare providers – as nicely as where a clinician could handle them. It was, in a word, limited.

Now, with many of those limits lifted at least briefly, hospitals, insurers and people are starting off to see some of the downstream consequences, and all get-togethers are wanting to know how digital treatment will seem, and what it will be like, when the pandemic is at last in the rearview mirror. 

Previously the sector is seeing utilization alter as a final result, and payment parity is on both of those payers’ and providers’ minds. 

THE Reward OF Virtual BEHAVIORAL Well being

Dr. William Lopez, countrywide director for digital treatment at main insurance provider Cigna, explained digital treatment available a pathway for its shoppers to seek treatment and was anything the organization actively inspired, especially for mental overall health providers. Right before the pandemic, he explained, digital visits built up just in excess of one% of all professional place of work visits that allowed for them. Right now, they make up just about 25%. This shift is expected to keep on, with a new study getting that 75% of People see a potential of healthcare at dwelling. 

“Virtual treatment has performed a especially crucial role in addressing mental overall health in the course of the pandemic,” explained Lopez. “There was also a sharp raise in the use of outpatient behavioral overall health providers, which rose by 27% when compared to pre-pandemic levels. In actuality, the progress of digital overall health has set behavioral treatment in just reach of far more individuals, with in excess of 60% of behavioral overall health shoppers conducting digital periods. Offered the relieve, comfort and accessibility of digital treatment – and the supplemental privacy that digital behavioral healthcare offers – we anticipate digital treatment to continue being in high demand submit-pandemic.”

Offered patients’ increased comfort with digital consultations, far more individuals than ever are requesting accessibility to telehealth. That, explained Lopez, could create a risk of overutilization submit-pandemic, but is on Cigna’s radar and is a thing to consider as the insurance provider continues to evolve its reimbursement and rewards ways.


The potential for overutilization and its financial expenditures is a extended-time period issue for Cigna and for all insurers. 

There is an escalating simply call for some of telehealth’s flexibilities, which have been state-of-the-art in the CARES Act, to keep on on a everlasting foundation, and this could have the downstream impact of costing non-public insurance policy corporations far more dollars.

Compensation for vendors is typically based mostly on factors these types of as the time expended with the affected person or how complex and risky the exam is to accomplish. The CARES Act mandates that telehealth visits be paid for at the exact same rate as in-human being visits for those insured by Medicare. Most non-public insurers followed match, shelling out vendors for telehealth visits at the exact same rate as in-human being providers.

Well being insurers want to redefine healthcare service provider condition licensing necessities, according to Reuters. They also inquire to be able to structure their rewards and offerings based mostly on the wants of their customers.

Insurers are inquiring policymakers for reimbursement flexibility and permission to use utilization administration applications. The numbers emphasize the rationale driving this request: In March 2020, non-public insurance provider claims for telehealth rose far more than four,000% when compared to the yr prior, mounting from .17% to 7.fifty two%. 

THE Fiscal Outcome

According to The Wall Street Journal, some large insurers are pulling back some of their telehealth coverage for non-COVID-19-relevant issues. UnitedHealthcare, for case in point, rolled back procedures previous drop that waived copays and other fees for non-coronavirus appointments. Anthem BlueCross BlueShield prolonged coverage by the end of 2020, but only the first two periods are free for the buyer.

Adding to the complication is that distinct insurance policy options and condition-funded Medicaid options have distinct policies for which treatment options they deal with. That implies some people are shelling out far more, and expenditures are starting to be complicated. Individuals could end up with a shock bill, or delay treatment entirely owing to charge.

Even now, insurers usually are not experience the pinch rather but. Most are just anticipating it. If something, profits between the main insurers are mainly up. This was backed up by a Kaiser Spouse and children Basis investigation launched this thirty day period demonstrating that, in 2020 at least, gross margins have been larger and professional medical loss ratios have been lessen than in 2019. Decline ratios in the Medicaid MCO sector have been lessen in 2020 than in 2019 or 2018.

Medicare Advantage insurers that drop shorter of expected loss ratio necessities for several years deal with supplemental penalties, together with the likelihood of being terminated. To keep away from this risk, KFF anticipates that some MA insurers with loss ratios beneath 85% could take the opportunity to provide new or far more generous excess rewards, these types of as fitness center memberships and dental or eyesight rewards, which are preferred and support to entice new enrollees. 

For Medicaid managed treatment companies, specified the solutions that states have to modify payments and risk-sharing agreements in the course of the pandemic, options could not be still left with unforeseen surpluses, or fail to reach their state’s professional medical loss ratio threshold this yr.

Waiving out-of-pocket expenditures for telehealth and COVID-19-relevant providers experienced the impact of escalating professional medical loss ratios and decreasing margins. An previously investigation printed on the Peterson-Kaiser Well being Technique Tracker found that just about 90% of enrollees in the individual and totally-insured team marketplaces have been in a system that waived charge-sharing for COVID-19 cure at some issue in the course of the pandemic. About 40% of enrollees in these marketplaces have been in options that available some variety of high quality credit score or reduction in 2020. 

Economical Treatment Act professional medical loss ratio rebates in 2021 are expected to overall in the billions of bucks for a 3rd consecutive yr. Personal and team sector insurers anticipate to fork out out $ billion in rebates to consumers this drop based mostly on their financial functionality in 2020, 2019 and 2018. Most of these rebates – an approximated $one.5 billion – are accounted for by individual sector insurers.

What all that implies is that the pandemic’s impact on overall health expending and insurers’ financial functionality in 2021 continues to be uncertain. Utilization has rebounded due to the fact the peak of the pandemic, and could rise further if pent-up demand spurs far more people to pursue providers.

Cigna, for its part, has weathered the uncertainty gracefully up to this issue, beating financial expectations in the course of the first quarter of 2021 with a $one.two billion earnings. Its general earnings reached $forty one billion in the course of the quarter, driven in significant part by its Evernorth overall health providers device, which incorporates pharmacy advantage manager Categorical Scripts. The device posted a thirteen% raise in earnings from the exact same time previous yr.

In its earnings report, Cigna projected 2021 adjusted earnings to be at least $166 billion, while the outlook for consolidated adjusted cash flow from operations is at least $7 billion. The projections aspect in potential problems from the pandemic.

“As we seem at the effects of the COVID-19 surroundings, adoption has been enormously accelerated, and this is specifically real with telehealth by the use of technological know-how to empower coordinated treatment that can be fulfilled in the dwelling,” explained Lopez. “We anticipate ongoing adoption and progress, not just from an affordability standpoint, but from a personalization standpoint.

“Write-up-pandemic, we will keep on to build sturdy scientific high quality applications that ensure equal or greater outcomes from digital treatment as when compared to equivalent in-human being treatment.”


With all of these complexities, should really payment parity for telehealth providers keep on? The answer is a complex just one.

A new Well being Affairs investigation examined both of those sides of the concern, and affordable arguments against payment parity exist. Telehealth could demand less scientific hard work than an in-human being pay a visit to, for case in point, and could also provide less worth. Importantly, telehealth could also have a larger potential for overuse.

Yet irrespective of that issue, there is minimal persuasive proof suggesting that continuing payment parity soon after the end of the pandemic will direct to runaway healthcare expending. In an investigation of Blue Cross Blue Defend of Michigan claims from January by October 2020, telehealth rose from zero to about half of all outpatient visits at the get started of the pandemic, but it settled at about 21% by October. 

Even though telehealth use is now twenty instances larger than it was prior to the pandemic, the overall amount of weekly outpatient visits has not exceeded pre-pandemic levels. In other words and phrases, telehealth has served as a substitute for in-human being treatment.

Even though fraud, abuse and overuse are valid considerations, they can be mitigated by aligning reimbursement for video and audio-only visits with the exact same evaluation and administration billing and documentation standards expected for in-human being visits, Well being Affairs found. CMS can use individual modifier codes for video clip-based mostly and audio-only telehealth to monitor and look into outliers for overuse and abuse.

The advice for professional insurers is to wait for sufficient info to properly estimate telehealth’s effects on accessibility, expenditures and high quality. In the meantime, they should really keep on payment parity soon after the public overall health emergency to let the technological know-how room to flourish in a far more “standard” surroundings, according to Well being Affairs. In shorter, telehealth has the potential to lower general healthcare expending and enhance accessibility and the affected person experience. 

Lopez explained Cigna continues to be committed.

“All over the pandemic, we’ve built positive all vendors are reimbursed for digital treatment at the exact same premiums as in-human being visits, and we’ve ongoing that motivation as the state recovers from the pandemic,” he explained. “This policy ensures everlasting coverage of digital treatment, offering shoppers ongoing accessibility to their medical doctor in a digital placing and coverage for typical providers executed just about. It will also let shoppers to pick out a new service provider and to be found just about for new affected person visits.

“We keep on to evaluate the correct reimbursement level for digital (treatment) submit-pandemic, using into account all of our stakeholders,” he explained.

HOW WE Got Listed here

Right before the coronavirus floor the entire world to a halt, telehealth was generally utilised in rural configurations, and was found as a way to deliver accessibility to those who lacked transportation or lived much away from the nearest healthcare facility.

Flash ahead to December 2020, when then Facilities for Medicare and Medicaid Solutions Administrator Seema Verma explained Congressional motion was required to hold telehealth from reverting to a rural advantage. That exact same thirty day period, CMS issued the 2021 Medicare medical professional price agenda closing rule and interim closing rule, which clarified which telehealth providers would be lined by Medicare, at least until the end of the yr of the public overall health emergency, on a everlasting or short term foundation.

For the duration of the public overall health emergency, CMS lifted the geographic restriction that beneficiaries have to be found in a rural place, and permitted beneficiaries to receive telehealth providers from their residences. It also allowed a broader variety of vendors to provide telehealth providers, these types of as actual physical therapists, occupational therapists and speech-language pathologists.

The company also included coverage and payment for audio-only kinds of telehealth, enabled rural overall health facilities to serve as eligible distant web pages, and expanded Medicare telehealth coverage to far more than one hundred supplemental providers.

These alterations have been established to expire soon after the end of the public overall health emergency, but teams these types of as the Medicare Payment Advisory Fee proposed to prolong telehealth flexibilities for a limited time so that far more proof could be collected about its effects on accessibility, utilization, high quality and expending.

For the duration of just one or two years of proof gathering, Medicare should really briefly fork out for specified telehealth providers, irrespective of a provider’s site, and CMS should really keep on to deal with freshly-lined telehealth providers and some audio-only treatment, MedPAC explained in March.

Twitter: @JELagasse
E mail the author: [email protected]